wpe18.jpg (1715 bytes)     wpe15.jpg (10063 bytes)    

    Table of Contents

Populations and Processes
Biogeochemical Dynamics
Paleoecology/Paleopedology
Water and Energy Dynamics
Disturbance
Synthesis


Section 1: Results from Prior Support

We produced 117 papers in refereed journals, 22 book chapters, 21 dissertations and theses, and 81 abstracts from national and international meetings. We supported a large number of graduate (36) and undergraduate ( 160) students and post doctoral fellows (5). Scientists at our site are involved in a number of LTER network activities, through comparative modeling studies, international collaborations, and development of new cross­site experiments. This section is organized by a modified version of the LTER core areas. Because of space constraints, comprehensive and more detailed results from our experiments and monitoring can be found on our World Wide Web data page.

Populations and Processes:

This work includes short­ and long­term population dynamics, food­web structure, as well as competition, ecophysiological, demographic and phenological, and genetic structure studies (see also Sections 2A , 2B , and 2E). Bouteloua gracilis (blue grama) is the most drought and grazing tolerant grass species and it is also the dominant plant species of the shortgrass steppe (SGS) (Milchunas et al. 1990, Lauenroth and Milchunas 1992). Similar to many other dominant perennial grasses in North American grasslands, blue grama recruits infrequently (Lauenroth et al. 1994) and has a long life span (Coffin and Lauenroth 1989, Lauenroth et al. 1996). Key processes for recruitment are seed production (Coffin and Lauenroth 1992)(Fig. 1.1), dispersal (Section 2A), establishment (Lauenroth et al. 1994, Section 2A), and competition from established individuals (Aguilera and Lauenroth 1993, 1995, Section 2A). Loss of this species results in more diverse but unstable systems (Fig. 1.2). Competition between blue grama and sub­dominant Buchloe dactyloides (buffalo grass) can be very intense under conditions of both low and high water and N availability (Aguiar 1995). Disturbance favors buffalo grass and drought favors blue grama (Aguiar et al. submitted, Aguiar 1995). Defoliation studies, assessing variables such as tiller and leaf dynamics, indicate that competition and defoliation act additively in interactions between blue grama and Agropyron smithii (western wheatgrass)(Gill 1992, Atsedu 1995). However, photosynthesis and stomatal conductance of western wheatgrass indicate positive responses to defoliation, which may explain its persistence even though it is a highly preferred species by a number of herbivores (Fahnestock and Detling, in prep). Ecophysiological and demographic responses of plants are often related to landscape topography and/or previous history (Milchunas et al. 1992, Gill 1992).

Our research on consumer populations ranges from swift foxes to nematodes. Fiftyfour of 68 captured swift foxes, a Category II species, have been radio­collared and ear tagged. Comparison with data from the late 1970's suggests a population increase over the past 20 years and that the Central Plains Experimental Range (CPER) has a higher density of foxes than the surrounding area (Fitzgerald, in prep). Coyote predation is the most important source of fox mortality.

Diets of great horned owls are composed mostly of lagomorphs, although most individual prey items taken are rodents (Fig. 1.3, Zimmerman et. al., submitted). Thirteen­lined ground squirrels and other rodents (Fig 1.4) are most abundant in shrublands in association with high orthopteran density (Higgens and Stapp 1995). The spatial distributions of shrubs and orthopterans concomitantly increase along a soil texture gradient from grassland (sandy loam) to shrubland (loamy sand) (Stapp 1995a, Stapp 1995b, Stapp 1994, Stapp et al. 1994, Stapp and Van Horne 1995). The shrubby, sandy lowlands in SGS appear very important to landscape­level biodiversity, even though the area of this habitat is small. Preliminary work on landscape­level plant diversity suggests a conceptually similar relationship; most of the diversity is concentrated in habitat types that make up a small proportion of the total landscape (Hazlett, unpublished).

Nematodes at the CPER occur within 6 orders, 23 families and 40 genera and fall into five trophic groups(i.e. bacterial feeders, fungivores, omnivores, predators, and plant parasites). Populations are approximately twice as large in soil under individuals of blue grama than in the interspaces between individuals and appear to be unaffected by grazing.

Our work on patterns in detrital food webs supports the "dynamics hypothesis" that food chain length is a function of the limitations that increased length places on the likelihood of the system recovering from a minor disturbance (Moore et al. 1993a, b, Moore and De Ruiter 1993, Moore et al. accepted, De Ruiter et al. submitted). A second important result is that the feasibility of food chains (ability to maintain positive population densities at steady state) is a function of productivity and detritus inputs. Higher levels of productivity sustain longer food chains. The conclusion of this work is that the energetic organization of communities forms the basis of ecosystem stability.

Biogeochemical Dynamics :

Our research in this area (Section 2B) encompasses spatial patterns of processes in native grassland, responses to manipulations and landuse, and fluxes of trace gases.

In addition to long­term monitoring of net primary production (Table 1.1, Fig. 1.5), we have been very active in issues concerning patterns and controls on primary production, as well as in assessing method-ological problems, developing new techniques, and spanning spatial scale issues (Boindini et al. 1991, Milchunas and Lauenroth 1992, Lauenroth and Sala 1992, Todd et. al 1993, McNaughton et al. in press). Early modeling and analytical work showed that traditional means of estimating NPP could lead to serious errors (Singh et al. 1984, Lauenroth et al. 1986, Sala et al. 1988). A long­term 14C experiment substantiated these findings, and provided realistic estimates of NPP and an alternative to error­prone methods (Milchunas and Lauenroth 1992).

Spatial patterns of aboveground net primary production (ANPP) at the CPER are controlled by location on catenas at a toposequence scale, and soil texture at the larger landscape scale (Liang et al. 1988). Soil texture is also an important control on plant functional types with different rooting distributions (Milchunas et al. 1992, Lee and Lauenroth 1994). Analyses of temporal patterns of ANPP showed a positive relationship with precipitation, but that ANPP was more variable than precipitation (Lauenroth and Sala 1992). An important result from comparing these data to a regional data set was that spatial and temporal relationships between ANPP and precipitation are not interchangeable (Fig. 1.6). Grazing has negative but small effects on ANPP and variability in cool­season precipitation has a large effect on ANPP (Milchunas et al. 1994).

The SGS is characterized by patchy plant cover and associated spatial heterogeneity of soil resources (Hook et al. 1991). Heterogeneity in soil organic matter (SOM) at this scale is as strong as that induced by topography, and is tightly associated with root biomass (Hook et al. 1994, Kelly et al. in press). Enrichment of C and N under plants is associated with perennial bunchgrasses (Vinton and Burke 1995), and develops at a rate that corresponds with plant community successional dynamics (Burke et al. 1995). Death in individual bunchgrasses results in rapid depletion (3 years) of the enriched zone with respect to mineralizable N and labile SOM pools, but heterogeneity of total C and N persists for decades (Fig. 1.8, Kelly and Burke, submitted).

Additional factors in small­scale nutrient distributions involves the influence of aboveground structures on erosion processes, and on the quality of inputs by different plant species. There is substantial accumulation of wind­ and water­transported material under blue grama and plains prickly­pear (Opuntia polyacantha). Grazing increases the movement from interspaces to underplants, and these effects are greatest in summit and midslope topographic positions (Burke et al. unpubl.). Plant species differ in quantity and quality of biomass, but differences in nutrient cycling under their canopies are slight (Vinton 1994). Soils under bunchgrasses had more microbial biomass and activity than under a rhizomatous grass, and soils under annuals had the highest mineralization rates. Comparing the importance of plant cover pattern to that of plant species effects across a gradient from the CPER to Konza, we found that plant cover pattern is most important in SGS, and plant species differences are most important in causing spatial pattern in tallgrass prairie (Vinton 1995).

SOM and nutrient availability are also strongly influenced by both soil texture and topographic position ( Fig. 1.7 , Hook and Burke in prep). In two long­term 15N studies (Delgado et al. 1995 and Hook et al. in prep), we have found that toeslope areas tend to retain up to 90% of 15N added 10years ago, while summits and midslopes retain half or less. Grazed pastures retain less 15N than ungrazed pastures.

Our trace gas flux studies (Mosier et al. 1991, 1993, 1994a,b, 1995, Bronson and Mosier 1994, Parton et al. 1994, Scholes et al. 1994) are confirming that aerobic SGS soils are important sinks for atmospheric CH4, and that gaseous N losses may be important to long­term N balance and productivity. Calculations using IPCC global warming potential indicate that the SGS has a net global warming capacity of ­1100 (sink for greenhouse gases), and N gas loss rates are similar to atmospheric inputs. Fertilization has a large effect on N2O emissions and CH4 uptake ( Fig. 1.9).

Paleoecology/Paleopedology:

In our investigation of paleosol geochemistry at the CPER, we proposed a Holocene paleoclimatic scenario (Kelly et al, 1993). A number of factors indicated that the early Holocene was cooler than either the mid­Holocene or current soil forming intervals, and that temperature has not increased from the mid­Holocene to the present (Blecker et al., in press). The 13C/12C ratios of paleosol SOM, phytoliths and CaCO3 established the dominance of C3 vegetation in the soil forming interval spanning 10,000­8,000 y.b.p., and the dominance of C4 vegetation in both the 5,000­3,000 y.b.p. and contemporary soil forming intervals (Kelly et al, 1993). Organic C and phytolith data suggest that both the early­ and mid­Holocene climatic conditions were more favorable for plant productivity than the present climate ( Fig. 1.10 , Kelly et al. submitted). This suggests cooler, moister conditions than presently occur. Pedon development in both the early and mid Holocene paleosols suggests wetter soil moisture regimes than in the present (Blecker, 1993).

Water and Energy Dynamics:

Water is the key driving variable for the dynamics of SGS ecosystems. Because of this, many of the interesting results of our work with soil water are best presented in the context of the response variables it controls (see other sections of this report).

Soil water monitoring data emphasize the interannual and seasonal variability in soil water as well as the critical role that soil texture plays in mediating storage and losses Fig. 1.11, Singh et al. in prep). Soil water availability is critical in controlling recruitment of blue grama (and probably other species) by influencing seed production, germination and establishment (Lauenroth et al. 1994, Section 2A). Soil water availability is closely related to ANPP (Singh et al. in prep). Relationships between ANPP and precipitation (see Biogeochemical Processes above) assume that precipitation is a good surrogate for soil water. At large temporal (growing season or larger) and spatial scales (km2 or larger) this is a good assumption.

Water losses (evaporation and transporation) are largely controlled by water availability. Energy to evaporate water is almost always far in excess of the supply as indicated by the annual or seasonal ratio of precipitation to potential evapotranspiration (Parton et al. 1981). Sala et al (1992) found that the probability of a ratio of precipitation to potential evapotranspiration >1 was only 0.1 at the daily scale and decreased exponentially to 0.01 at the monthly scale. Quantifying bare soil evaporation and understanding how it is affected by soil texture are critical issues in understanding water loss. Results from an experiment with mini­lysimeters confirm a 2­stage water loss pattern with a short period of high water loss followed by a long period in which losses decrease exponentially (Wythers et al. in prep). By contrast, the mini­lysimeter results contradict the idea that the depth to which evaporation can remove water from a soil decreases as coarseness of soil texture increases. We found the greatest depth of loss for a coarse sand.

Many of our questions about structure and function of SGS ecosystems require an understanding of long­term patterns of soil water dynamics. We used a simulation model to generate 30 years of soil water data for the CPER to provide this long­term view (Sala et al. 1992). Several key results were identified by this work. First, the general temporal pattern in soil water at the daily scale is not identical to the pattern in precipitation because of an interacting pattern of atmospheric demand. The peak in average soil water precedes the peak in average precipitation by almost a month. Second, the layer that most frequently had available water was very shallow (4­15 cm) ( Fig. 1.12 ). Layers above this were drier because of bare soil evaporation and layers below because most precipitation events are too small to move water that deep in the soil. Third, on average water penetrated to 100 cm (Fig. 1.12 ). In wet years, it reached 135 cm but in dry years it only reached 45 cm. These data provide important information for understanding vegetation structure in the SGS.

Disturbances:

Our work in this area is extensive. We divide this section into natural and human­induced disturbances (see Conceptual Framework Section 2 for distinctions). Currently landcover in the SGS is 60% cropland and 40% native grassland grazed by cattle (Burke et al. 1993).

Natural disturbances: The majority of natural disturbances are small (<100 m2) and there is an inverse relationship between size and frequency (Coffin and Lauenroth 1989). The most frequent disturbances (cattle fecal pats, harvester ant nest sites, root feeding invertebrates, and burrows from small animals) produce patches that range in size from 5­40 cm diameter ( Fig. 1.13 , Hook et al. 1994) and are important in shaping plant community structure and diversity across the landscape (Coffin and Lauenroth 1990). An important focus of our natural disturbance work has been the effect of disturbances on individuals of blue grama and its subsequent recolonization of disturbed patches. Previous studies had reported that blue grama can not recover after disturbance. In a study designed to look at the effects of patch size and neighbors on blue grama seedling growth and survival, we found that in openings <30 cm diameter, established neighbors could preempt resources and inhibit seedling establishment (Aguilera and Lauenroth 1993). Openings >30 cm were large enough to result in seedling establishment. Hook et al. (1994) reached a similar conclusion about the size of a regeneration gap based upon how the root systems of neighbors explored patches created by disturbances ( Fig. 1.14 ). Simulation analyses and assessments of recovery on abandoned fields (see below) confirm that blue grama does reestablish following a disturbance although in some situations the rate may be quite slow ( Fig. 1.15 , Coffin and Lauenroth 1990, Coffin et al. 1996, Lauenroth et al. 1994). Recovery rates are dependent upon the characteristics of the disturbance, and in particular size and soil texture (Coffin and Lauenroth 1994, Coffin et al. 1993).

Root feeding by white grubs (June Beetle larvae) can cause mortality of blue grama over areas ranging from 0.1 to 100s of m2. A long­term experiment to follow recovery on grazed and ungrazed areas affected by white grubs (Coffin et al. submitted, Table 1.1, Section 2E) has produced the following results: 1. successional dynamics of plant functional types on patches affected by white grubs were similar to other disturbances; 2. strong relationships between survival of blue grama on the affected patches and cover on ungrazed areas indicate the importance of initial conditions; 3. the importance of grazing increased over time and the importance of initial conditions decreased.

Human­induced disturbances:
We are continuing our research on the recovery of plants and soils on abandoned agricultural fields along precipitation and temperature gradients in Pawnee National Grasslands and soil texture gradients at the CPER (Burke et al. 1995, Coffin et al. 1996). We found a large variability in recovery of the vegetation that could not be explained by climatic factors. Recovery may be related to soil texture, since the ability of blue grama to recover through seedling establishment is affected by silt content of the soil (Lauenroth et al. 1994). Net N mineralization and other indicators of active SOM were lowest on cultivated fields, but were not significantly different between abandoned and native fields. Recovery of SOM in abandoned fields appears to involve accumulation of C and N under perennial plants. Higher N mineralization and turnover in cultivated fields may make them more susceptible to N losses (Ihori et al. 1995a), and recovery of N cycling in abandoned fields appears to involve a return to slower N turnover and tighter N cycling similar to native SGS. Although variation in native soil C and N correlated with climate and soil texture (Ihori et al. 1995b), soil losses due to cultivation were not explained by these variables. Rates of recovery were small compared with loss rates due to cultivation( Fig 1.16 ).

We are also assessing recovery on nutrient­enrichment treatments (Lauenroth et al. 1978). Invasions by exotic species and the development of characteristics of highly disturbed plant communities did not occur until several years after treatments were terminated ( Fig. 1.17 , Milchunas and Lauenroth 1995). The tendency of existing plant populations to continue to occupy a site when conditions become unfavorable, can create time­lags in response that represent important challenges for environmental monitoring. The existence of time­lags means that an ecosystem can pass through a threshold to an alternate state before it is detectable in species composition. These results have important implications for such things as global climate change and sulfur and nitrogen oxide pollution which also have the potential to act as enrichment stressors.

The SGS has a long evolutionary history of grazing by large herbivores. The importance of this force in shaping current­day structure and function of this system, and the importance of cattle grazing on both public and private land, have been reasons for the emphasis in research at this site in plant­animal interactions and long­term effects of grazing. Research in this area spans all five major areas. Although differences among plant communities on different grazing treatments have been found to be relatively minor (Milchunas et al. 1989), long­term ungrazed SGS plant communities are more similar to disturbed than were long­term grazed communities (Milchunas et al. 1990). Ungrazed compared to heavily grazed communities were found to be more susceptible to invasion by "weed" species ( Fig. 1.18, Milchunas et al. 1992). Current­year defoliation does have important effects on individual plants and on nutrient uptake by plants (Milchunas et al. 1995, Varnamkhasti et al. 1995). Increased forage quality in response to defoliation suggests a positive feedback between plants and grazers.

Although plant population changes with grazing are minor, other populations display a wide range ofresponses to grazing ( Fig.1.19 , Milchunas et al. in prep.). Groups such as aboveground arthropods, birds, and lagomorphs show large changes in abundance, dominance, or diversity in response to grazing, whereas groups such as microarthropods and nematodes show very little change. Endemic birds associated with SGS prefer to nest in heavily rather than lightly grazed treatments. Changes in biodiversity do not relate to changes in other structural or functional characteristics of the ecosystem.

Little or no effects of grazing on root and crown biomass have been observed (Milchunas and Lauenroth 1989). On average, ANPP declines slightly with grazing ( Fig. 1.20 , Milchunas et al. 1994), but differences between treatments can shift depending upon levels of water resource and current­year defoliation (Varnamkhasti et al. 1995). Soil nitrogen and carbon pools are not affected at moderate intensities of grazing (Burke et al. submitted), but have lower values than ungrazed treatments in heavily grazed lowlands (Milchunas and Lauenroth 1993).

In a grazing experiment initiated in 1991, we are examining long­term grazed and protected and newly ungrazed and protected SGS at 6 sites at the CPER ( Section 2E , Table 1.1). Key results to date focus on C and N dynamics. Total soil C and N pools were unaffected by moderate grazing or exclosure following both 2 and 53 years of treatment ( Fig. 1.21 , Burke et al. submitted). Pools representing recent belowground litter inputs and substrate available for decomposition (particulate SOM and microbial biomass) were also unaffected by grazing treatments. However, mineralizable C and N, representing the most active pools of SOM, were significantly higher under long­term exclosure than long­term grazing, but only in bare soil areas between plants. Small decreases in mineralization may reflect slight erosion due to reduced canopy and litter cover, but the overall small effects of grazing may be due to increased plant basal cover that ameliorates thermal effects of reduced litter.

Synthesis:
We have produced many synthesis products (
Table 1.5) over the past 5 years. Chief among our accomplishments is our simulation models, which we have linked to represent the interactions of plant communities, ecosystem dynamics (nutrient cycling and trace gas flux), and soil water. We describe our current activities in detail in Section 2F.

 

wpe36.jpg (1101 bytes)

wpe12.jpg (1377 bytes)                             wpe13.jpg (1298 bytes)                        wpe39.jpg (1211 bytes)  

 

04/12/01 


About - Reports - Research - Data - Publications - Personnel -
News -
Links - What's New - Web Site Map - Home

To contact us, please email: Sallie Sprague  (Sallie.Sprague@colostate.edu)